Is The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story coming back?

<SHOW>’s return is unconfirmed. The show last aired on February 11, 2026, with its third episode, and is currently between seasons as of May 8, 2026.

The series is a crime documentary that premiered in 2026 on Hulu. It investigates the real-life case of Cassie Stoddart, a high school student who was found stabbed to death in Pocatello, Idaho. The show explores the events leading up to the murder, focusing on the last moments of Cassie’s life and the subsequent police investigation. It raises questions about the involvement of her classmates and features a discovery of a buried video tape that added new complexity to the case.

The episodes each run approximately 45 minutes, providing an in-depth look at the case and the community’s reaction to the tragedy.