Is Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries coming back?

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is currently airing on UP TV; the next episode airs May 14, 2026. The series premiered on April 20, 2025, and follows Cheryl Cooper, who moves to an Amish community in Sugarcreek, Ohio, after a failed engagement. Set in the drama and crime genres, the show depicts her managing a gift shop while becoming involved in various local mysteries. Cheryl’s sharp instincts and outsider perspective often help uncover truths within the close-knit community. The show was a drama series that aired in 2025 and is still ongoing. It explores themes of community, mystery, and personal growth as Cheryl navigates her new life and the secrets of Sugarcreek. The cast includes Galadriel Stineman as Cheryl Cooper, Denise Gossett as Naomi Miller, Kevin Joy as Levi Miller, Lance E. Nichols as Chief Twitchell, Ryan O'Quinn as Seth Miller, and Riley Beeson as young Naomi Miller.